1/33:bhogottarapadāt khavidhāne anirdeśaḥ pūrvapadārthahitatvāt | bhogottarapadāt khavidhāne anirdeśaḥ |*
2/33:agamakaḥ nirdeśaḥ anirdeśaḥ |
3/33:kim kāraṇam |
4/33:pūrvapadārthahitatvāt |
5/33:uttarapadārthapradhānaḥ tatpuruṣaḥ pūrvapadārthapradhāne ca pratyayaḥ iṣyate |
6/33:pitṛbhogāya hite prāpnoti pitre ca eva hite iṣyate |
7/33:evam tarhi bhogīnarpratyayaḥ vijñāsyate |
8/33:bhogīnar iti cet vāvacanam |*
9/33:bhogīnar iti yadi pratyayaḥ vidhīyate vāvacanam kartavyam mātrīyaḥ pitrīyaḥ iti api yathā syāt |
10/33:rājācāryābhyām nityam | rājācāryābhyām nityam iti vaktavyam |*
11/33:rājabhogīnaḥ |
12/33:ācāryāt aṇatvam ca |
13/33:ācāryabhogīnaḥ |
14/33:kim bhogīnarpratyayaḥ vidhīyate iti ataḥ rājācāryābhyām nityam iti vaktavyam |
15/33:na iti āha |
16/33:sarvathā rājācāryābhyām nityam iti vaktavyam |
17/33:iha ca grāmaṇibhogīnaḥ senānibhogīnaḥ iti uttarapade iti hrasvatvam na prāpnoti |
18/33:iha ca abbhoginaḥ iti apaḥ bhi iti tatvam prāpnoti |
19/33:sūtram ca bhidyate |
20/33:yathānyāsam eva astu |
21/33:nanu ca uktam bhogottarapadāt khavidhāne anirdeśaḥ pūrvapadārthahitatvāt iti |
22/33:na eṣaḥ doṣaḥ |
23/33:ayam bhogaśabdaḥ asti eva dravyapadārthakaḥ |
24/33:tat yathā bhogavān ayam deśaḥ iti ucyate yasmin gāvaḥ sasnāni ca vartante |
25/33:asti kriyāpadārthakaḥ |
26/33:tat yathā bhogavān ayam brāhmaṇaḥ iti ucyate yaḥ samyak snānādīḥ kriyāḥ anubhavati |
27/33:tat yaḥ kriyāpadārthakaḥ tasya ayam grahaṇam |
28/33:yaḥ ca pitṛsthābhyaḥ kriyābhyaḥ hitaḥ sambandhāt asau pitre api hitaḥ bhavati |
29/33:yadi sambandhāt astu dravyapadārthakasya api grahaṇam |
30/33:yaḥ api hi pitṛdravyāya hitaḥ sambandhāt asau pitre hitaḥ bhavati |
31/33:atha vā bhogaśabdaḥ śarīravācī api drśyate |
32/33:tat yathā ahiḥ iva bhogaiḥ paryeti bāhum iti| ahiḥ iva śarīraiḥ iti gamyate |
33/33:evam pitṛśarīrāya hitaḥ pitṛbhogīṇaḥ iti |

1/17:khavidhāne pañcajanāt upasaṅkhyānam | khavidhāne pañcajanāt upasaṅkhyānam kartavyam |*
2/17:pañcajanāya hitaḥ pañcajanīnaḥ |
3/17:samānādhikaraṇe iti vaktavyam |
4/17:yaḥ hi pañcānām janāya hitaḥ pañcajanīyaḥ saḥ bhavati |
5/17:sarvajanāt ṭhañ ca | sarvajanāt ṭhañ vaktavyaḥ khaḥ ca |*
6/17:sarvajanāya hitaḥ sārvajanikaḥ sārvajanīnaḥ |
7/17:samānādhikaraṇe iti ca vaktavyam |
8/17:yaḥ hi sarveṣām janāya hitaḥ sarvajanīyaḥ saḥ |
9/17:mahājanāt nityam | mahājanāt nityam ṭhañ vaktavyaḥ |*
10/17:mahājanāya hitaḥ māhājanikaḥ |
11/17:tatpuruṣe iti vaktavyam bahuvrīhau mā bhūt iti |
12/17:mahān janaḥ asya mahājanaḥ mahājanāya hitaḥ mahājanīyaḥ |
13/17:yadi tarhi atiprasaṅgāḥ santi iti upādhiḥ kriyate ādyanyāse api upādhiḥ kartavyaḥ |
14/17:ātmanviśvajane samānādhikaraṇe iti vaktavyam |
15/17:yaḥ his viśveṣām janāya hitaḥ viśvajanīyaḥ saḥ bhavati |
16/17:atha matam etat anabhidhānāt ādyanyāse na bhaviṣyati iti iha api na arthaḥ upādhigrahaṇena |
17/17:iha api anabhidhānāt na bhaviṣyati |

ātman viśvajana ityetābhyāṃ bhogottarapadāc ca prātipadikāt khaḥ pratyayo bhavati tasmai hitam ityetasmin viṣaye. chasya apavādaḥ. ātmanniti nalopo na kṛtaḥ prakṛtiparimāṇajñāpanārtham. tena uttarapadagrahaṇam bhogaśabdena eva sambadhyate, na tu pratyekam. ātmane hitam ātmanīnam. ātmādhvānau khe 6-4-169 iti prakṛtibhāvaḥ. viśvajanebhyo hitam viśvajanīnam. karmadhārayādeva iṣyate. ṣaṣṭhīsamāsād bahuvrīheśca cha eva bhavati. viśvajanāya hitam viśvajanīyam. pañcajanādupasaṅkhyānam. pañcajanāc ca khaḥ. atra api karmadhārayādiṣyate. pañcajanīnam. anyatra pañcajanīyam. sarvajānāṭ ṭhañ khaśca. sārvajanikam, sarvajanīnam. atra api karmadhārayādeva. sarvajanīyam anyatra. mahājanānnityaṃ ṭhañ vaktavyaḥ. mahājanāya hitam māhājanikam. tatpuruṣādeva. bahuvrīhes tu cha eva bhavati. mahājanīyam. bhogottarapadāt khalvapi mātṛbhogīṇaḥ. pitṛbhogīṇaḥ. bhogaśabdaḥ śarīravācī. kevalebhyo mātrādibhyaḥ cha eva bhavati. mātrīyam. pitiriyam. rājācāryābhyāṃ tu nityam. bhogottarapadābhyam eva khaḥ pratyayaḥ iṣyate, na kevalābhyām. rājabhogīnaḥ. ācāryādaṇatvaṃ ca. ācāryabhogīnaḥ. kevalābhyāṃ vākyam eva bhavati, rājñe hitam, ācāryāya hitam iti.

ātmanviśvajanabhogauttarapadāt khaḥ 5.1.9 ātman viśvajana ityetābhyāṃ bhogottarapadāc ca prātipadikāt khaḥ pratyayo bhavati tasmai hitam ityetasmin viṣaye. chasya apavādaḥ. ātmanniti nalopo na kṛtaḥ prakṛtiparimāṇajñāpanārtham. tena uttarapadagrahaṇam bhogaśabdena eva sambadhyate, na tu pratyekam. ātmane hitam ātmanīnam. ātmādhvānau khe 6.4.169 iti prakṛtibhāvaḥ. viśvajanebhyo hitam viśvajanīnam. karmadhārayādeva iṣyate. ṣaṣṭhīsamāsād bahuvrīheśca cha eva bhavati. viśvajanāya hitam viśvajanīyam. pañcajanādupasaṅkhyānam. pañcajanāc ca khaḥ. atra api karmadhārayādiṣyate. pañcajanīnam. anyatra pañcajanīyam. sarvajānāṭ ṭhañ khaśca. sārvajanikam, sarvajanīnam. atra api karmadhārayādeva. sarvajanīyam anyatra. mahājanānnityaṃ ṭhañ vaktavyaḥ. mahājanāya hitam māhājanikam. tatpuruṣādeva. bahuvrīhes tu cha eva bhavati. mahājanīyam. bhogottarapadāt khalvapi mātṛbhogīṇaḥ. pitṛbhogīṇaḥ. bhogaśabdaḥ śarīravācī. kevalebhyo mātrādibhyaḥ cha eva bhavati. mātrīyam. pitiriyam. rājācāryābhyāṃ tu nityam. bhogottarapadābhyam eva khaḥ pratyayaḥ iṣyate, na kevalābhyām. rājabhogīnaḥ. ācāryādaṇatvaṃ ca. ācāryabhogīnaḥ. kevalābhyāṃ vākyam eva bhavati, rājñe hitam, ācāryāya hitam iti.

ātmanvi�ājanabogottarapadāt? khaḥ. , 5.1.9 ayātmannityatra nalopaḥ kasmānna kṛtaḥ, yāvatā dvandvenāyaṃ nirdeśaḥ kriyate, tatra "nalopaḥ prātipadikāntasya" (8.2.7) iti nalopaḥ prāpnoti? ityata āha-"ātman()" ityādi. ātmannityeva bhavatyeṣā prākṛtiriti jñāpanārthaṃ nalopo na kṛtaḥ. kaḥ punarevaṃ sati viśeṣaḥ? ityāha-"tena" ityādi. gatārtham(). yadyevam(), vi()ājanaśabdena hruttarapadasya sambandhaḥ prāpnoti? evaṃ manyate-ātmanniti nalopābāvena pratyekaṃ vākyaparisamāptevryabhicārasya darśitatvāt? tataḥ pratyāsaterbhogaśabdenaiva sambadhyate, na tu vi()ājanaśabdeneti nāsati doṣaḥ. "karmadhārayādeveṣyate" iti. vāryapāramparyopadeśāt(). vibhāvāgrahaṇānuvṛttevryavasthitavibāṣāvijñānādvedaṃ veditavyam(). vi()āsya jano vi()ājanaḥ, vi()āo jano'syeti vi()ājana iti samāsena bhavitavyam(). yathā kho na bhavati tathā ccho'pi na bhavatītyāśaṅkyāha-"bahuvrīhistu" ityādi. "upasaṃkhyānam()" iti. pratipādanamarthaḥ. tatredaṃ pratipādanam()-iha hi bhogasamāsāditi vāktavye uttarapadagrahaṇamadhikavidhānārtham(). na caivaṃ sati bahupūrvādīṣadasamāptau bhogo bahubhoga ityasmāt? khaḥ syādityāśaṅkanīyam(); bahucpracpratyayasya samāsābāvāt(). tato'tri chenaiva bhavitavyam()--bahubhogīya iti. tena pañcajanādapi bhaviṣyati. saṃjñāśabdaścāyam(); "diksaṃkhye saṃjñāyām()" 2.1.49 iti samāsaḥ. tathā sarvajanādapi veditavyaḥ. "tatpuruṣādeva" iti. viśeṣānabhidhāne'pi mahājanāditi nirdeśādeva samānādhikaraṇādeva bhogaśabdo'yaṃ bhāvasādhanaḥ--bhuktirbhoga iti, karmasādhano vā--bhujyata iti bhoga iti. ayamavyutpannaḥ śarīravācīsa, tasyeha grahaṇamityāha--"bhogaśabdaḥ" ityādi. bhogaśabdaḥ śarīrameva pratipādayatītyarthaḥ. yatra vatrtamāno'yaṃ sākṣāt? sambandhamāha, tatraiva khapratyayamāsādayati. vatrtate ca kriyāyāṃ dravye ca. tathā hi--yadyapi bhujikriyayā dravyeṇa ca sambandho'sti, tathāpi śarīreṇa mukhyaḥ sambandha iti tato bhavati pratyayaḥ. yathā rājācāryābhyāṃ vākyameva bhavati, tathehāpi bhavitavryāmiti yaścodayet(), taṃ pratyāha--"ācāryādaṇatvam()" iti. kṣubhnādipāṭhāt(). "kevalābhyāṃ vākyameva bhavata#i" iti. chapratyayo na bhavati, anarbhidhānādeva॥

ātmanvi\ufffdājana. atmajan, vi\ufffdājana, bhogottarapada-ebhyo hitamityarthe khaḥ syādityarthaḥ. `ātmanīna'mityudāharaṇaṃ vakṣyati.

ātmanvi�ājanabhogottarapadātkhaḥ 1648, 5.1.9 ātmanvi()ājana. atmajan, vi()ājana, bhogottarapada-ebhyo hitamityarthe khaḥ syādityarthaḥ. "ātmanīna"mityudāharaṇaṃ vakṣyati.