pratyayārthaviśeṣaṇam etat. tṛtīyāsamarthāt prokte ṇiniḥ pratyayo bhavati yat proktaṃ purāṇaproktāśced brāhmaṇakalpās te bhavanti. purāṇena cirantanena muninā proktāḥ. brāhmaṇeṣu tāvat bhāllavinaḥ. śāṭyāyaninaḥ. aitareyiṇaḥ. kalpeṣu paiṅgī kalpaḥ. āruṇaparājī. purāṇaprokteṣu iti kim? yājñavalkāni brāhmaṇāni. āśmarathaḥ kalpaḥ yājñavalkyādayo 'cirakālā ityākhyāneṣu vārtā. tathā vyavaharati sūtrakāraḥ. tadviṣayatā kasmān na bhavati? pratipadaṃ brāhmaṇesu yaḥ pratyayas tasya tadviṣayatā vidhīyate ṇineḥ. ayaṃ tu yājñavalkyaśabdasya kaṇvādiṣu pāṭhādaṇ. na vā 'yaṃ yogaś chando 'dhikāram anuvartayati, tena kalpeṣvapi na bhavati. purāṇa iti nipātanāt tuḍabhāvaḥ. na vā atyantabādhaiva, tena purātanam ityapi bhavati.

purāṇaprokteṣu brāhmaṇakalpeṣu 4.3.105 pratyayārthaviśeṣaṇam etat. tṛtīyāsamarthāt prokte ṇiniḥ pratyayo bhavati yat proktaṃ purāṇaproktāśced brāhmaṇakalpās te bhavanti. purāṇena cirantanena muninā proktāḥ. brāhmaṇeṣu tāvat bhāllavinaḥ. śāṭyāyaninaḥ. aitareyiṇaḥ. kalpeṣu paiṅgī kalpaḥ. āruṇaparājī. purāṇaprokteṣu iti kim? yājñavalkāni brāhmaṇāni. āśmarathaḥ kalpaḥ yājñavalkyādayo 'cirakālā ityākhyāneṣu vārtā. tathā vyavaharati sūtrakāraḥ. tadviṣayatā kasmān na bhavati? pratipadaṃ brāhmaṇesu yaḥ pratyayas tasya tadviṣayatā vidhīyate ṇineḥ. ayaṃ tu yājñavalkyaśabdasya kaṇvādiṣu pāṭhādaṇ. na vā 'yaṃ yogaś chando 'dhikāram anuvartayati, tena kalpeṣvapi na bhavati. purāṇa iti nipātanāt tuḍabhāvaḥ. na vā atyantabādhaiva, tena purātanam ityapi bhavati.

purāṇaprokteṣu brāāhṛṇakalpeṣu. , 4.3.105 "bhāllavinaḥ"iti. bhāllavaḥ, śāṭa()āyanaḥ,aitareya-- ityetebhyaḥ proktārthe ṇiniḥ. tadantāt "tadadhīte" 4.2.58 ityutpannasya "poktālluk" 4.2.63 "chandobrāāhamaṇāni" 4.2.65 ityādinā tadviṣayatā. "paiṅgī" iti. "āruṇaparājī" iti. piṅgāruṇaparājaśabdābhyāṃ ṇiniḥ. "yājñavalkāni" iti. "āśmarathaḥ" iti. yājñavalkya()āravyaśabdābhyāṃ gargādiyañantābhyāṃ "kaṇvādibhyo gotre" 4.2.58 ityutpannasya, "āpatyasya" 6.4.151 ityādinā yalopaḥ. nanu yājñavalkādīnyapi purāṇaproktānyeva brāāhṛṇāni, brāāhṛṇāntaraiḥ purāṇaproktestulyatvāt? ityāha-- "yājñavalkya" ityādi. ākhyāneṣu hreṣā vātrtā -- yājñavalkyādayo'parakālāḥ pravaktāro'nyebhyaḥ pravaktṛbhyaḥ. tathā ca vastutvamanapekṣya vyavaharati sūtrakāra ityadoṣaḥ. "tadviṣayatā kasmānna bhavati" (iti). "chandobrāāhṛṇāni" 4.2.65 ityādineti bhāvaḥ. "pratipadam" ityādi. lakṣaṇapratipadoktaparibhāṣayā (vyā.pa.3) hi pratipadaṃ viśeṣaṇam. brāāhṛṇamuccārya brāāhṛṇeṣu yaḥ pratyayo vihitastasya tadviṣayatā vidhīyate. tasmāt tadviṣayatāsya na bhavati. kalpeṣu tarhi kasmānna bhavati; yathā-- kāśyapena proktaṃ kalpamadhīyate kāśyapina ityatra? "na cāyam" ityādi. chando'dhikāre ye yogastadvihitasya pratyayasya tadviṣayatā bhavati, na cāyaṃ yogaśchando'dhikāramanuvatrtate;tenaitadvihitasya pratyayasyādhyetṛveditṛviṣayatā kalpeṣu na bhavati-- paiṅgī kalpaḥ, āruṇaparājī kalda iti. purāṇa iti ko'yaṃ śabdaḥ, yāvatā "sāṃyaciram" (4.3.23) ityādinā ṭa()uṭa()uloḥ sanniyogena tuṭi kṛte purātanamiti bhavitavyam? ityata āha-- "purāṇa iti nipātanāt tuḍabhāvaḥ (iti). yadyevam, na bhavati purātanam? ityāha-- "{na vā kāśikā}na ca" ityādi. nanu "bādhakānyapi nipātanāni" (vī.pa.vṛ.109) ityato bhavitavyameva vācakeneti? avācakānyapi (nī.pa.vṛ.110). abādhakānyapi bhavanti, etacca "śaderagatau taḥ" 7.3.42 ityatra pratipāditam॥

purāṇaprokteṣu. `tena prokta'miti, `ṇini'riti cānuvartate. mantravyatiriktavedabhāgā brāāhṛṇāni. bodhāyanādikalpasūtrāṇikalpāḥ. tathābhūteṣu purātanamuniprokteṣu grantheṣu vācyeṣu tṛtīyāntāṇṇiniḥ syādityarthaḥ. tadāha– tṛtīyāntāditi. yatproktamiti. sāmānyābhiprāyamekavacanam. pratyayābhidheyaṃ yatproktaṃ tatpurātanamuniproktabrāāhṛṇakalpātmakaṃ cediti yāvat. `purāṇaprokta'mityetadvyācaṣṭe–purāṇeneti. brāāhṛṇe udāharati–bhallu-bhāllavina iti. bhallu iti prakṛtinirdeśaḥ. bhallunā purātanamuninā proktānbrāāhṛṇabhāgānadhīyate ityartho proktārthaṇiniḥ. bhāllavinśabdādadhyetraṇo luki `bhāllavina' iti rūpamiti bhāvaḥ. brāāhṛṇe udāharaṇāntaramāha–śāṭha\ufffdāyana śāṭha\ufffdāyanina iti. śāṭha\ufffdāyaneti prakṛtinirdeśaḥ. śāṭha\ufffdāyanena purātanamuninā proktānbrāāhṛṇabhāgānadhīyate ityarthe proktārthaṇini pratyaye śāṭha\ufffdāyaninśabdādhyetraṇo luki `śāṭha\ufffdāyanina' iti rūpamityarthaḥ. kalpe iti. `udāhyiyate' iti śeṣaḥ. piṅga- paihgī kalpa iti. piṅgeti prakṛtinirdeśaḥ. piṅgena purātanamuninā prokta ityarthe ṇinau rūpam.

purāṇaprokteṣu brāāhṛṇakalpeṣu 1464, 4.3.105 purāṇaprokteṣu. "tena prokta"miti, "ṇini"riti cānuvartate. mantravyatiriktavedabhāgā brāāhṛṇāni. bodhāyanādikalpasūtrāṇikalpāḥ. tathābhūteṣu purātanamuniprokteṣu grantheṣu vācyeṣu tṛtīyāntāṇṇiniḥ syādityarthaḥ. tadāha--tṛtīyāntāditi. yatproktamiti. sāmānyābhiprāyamekavacanam. pratyayābhidheyaṃ yatproktaṃ tatpurātanamuniproktabrāāhṛṇakalpātmakaṃ cediti yāvat. "purāṇaprokta"mityetadvyācaṣṭe--purāṇeneti. brāāhṛṇe udāharati--bhallu-bhāllavina iti. bhallu iti prakṛtinirdeśaḥ. bhallunā purātanamuninā proktānbrāāhṛṇabhāgānadhīyate ityartho proktārthaṇiniḥ. bhāllavinśabdādadhyetraṇo luki "bhāllavina" iti rūpamiti bhāvaḥ. brāāhṛṇe udāharaṇāntaramāha--śāṭha()āyana śāṭha()āyanina iti. śāṭha()āyaneti prakṛtinirdeśaḥ. śāṭha()āyanena purātanamuninā proktānbrāāhṛṇabhāgānadhīyate ityarthe proktārthaṇini pratyaye śāṭha()āyaninśabdādhyetraṇo luki "śāṭha()āyanina" iti rūpamityarthaḥ. kalpe iti. "udāhyiyate" iti śeṣaḥ. piṅga-paihgī kalpa iti. piṅgeti prakṛtinirdeśaḥ. piṅgena purātanamuninā prokta ityarthe ṇinau rūpam.